refactor: remove WAT/WASM generator (superseded by IR→Rust→WASM path)

- Deleted compiler/src/generators/wasm.ts (472 lines)
- Deleted compiler/src/runtime/wasm-host.ts (165 lines)
- Deleted compiler/__tests__/e2e-wasm.test.ts (203 lines)
- Removed WASM import and generation call from compiler/src/index.ts
- Removed WASMGenerated from TS generator state enum literals
- Removed WASM codegen tests from parser.test.ts
- All 37 tests passing

The WASM generator was architecturally wrong: every Map/Set operation
crossed the WASM→JS boundary, creating 45-55% overhead for a module
that doesn't compute anything. WASM will be a byproduct of the Rust
backend via wasm-pack instead (M2.1).

Closes #19
This commit is contained in:
cos Agent 2026-05-09 22:03:06 -07:00 • committed by Scott Scoble
parent bc067d239c
commit 00dd745ef2
15 changed files with 437 additions and 925 deletions

1
.gitignore vendored Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1 @@
out/

View file

@ -1,203 +0,0 @@
import { describe, it, expect } from 'vitest';
import { parseSpeckContent } from '../src/parser.js';
import { generateWASM } from '../src/generators/wasm.js';
import { createHostImports, bindMemory, readScalarState } from '../src/runtime/wasm-host.js';
import fs from 'fs';
import path from 'path';
import os from 'os';
// Dynamic import wabt since it's a CommonJS module
async function loadWabt() {
const wabt = await import('wabt');
return wabt.default();
}
describe('SpeckDL WASM E2E', () => {
it('should compile Counter speck to WAT, assemble to WASM, and run in Node.js', async () => {
// A minimal scalar-only speck that we can fully compile and run
// NOTE: Parser requires braces on the SAME line as block keywords
const speckSource = `speck Counter {
author: "Speckl Compiler v0.3"
source: document ref "WASM-E2E"
review: automated
state: {
count: Nat := 0
maxCount: Nat := 10
}
init: {
count := 0
maxCount := 10
}
action Increment() {
require count < maxCount
count := count + 1
}
action Decrement() {
require count > 0
count := count - 1
}
action Reset() {
count := 0
}
action GetCount() {
return count
}
}`;
// 1. Parse
const ast = parseSpeckContent(speckSource);
expect(ast.specks).toHaveLength(1);
expect(ast.specks[0].name).toBe('Counter');
// 2. Generate WAT to temp dir
const tmpDir = fs.mkdtempSync(path.join(os.tmpdir(), 'speckl-wasm-e2e-'));
generateWASM(ast, tmpDir);
const watPath = path.join(tmpDir, 'Counter.wat');
expect(fs.existsSync(watPath)).toBe(true);
const watContent = fs.readFileSync(watPath, 'utf-8');
expect(watContent).toContain('(module');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "init")');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "Increment")');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "Decrement")');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "Reset")');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "GetCount")');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "getState")');
expect(watContent).toContain('(export "memory")');
// 3. Assemble WAT → WASM using wabt
const wabtModule = await loadWabt();
const wasmModule = wabtModule.parseWat('Counter.wat', watContent);
wasmModule.resolveNames();
wasmModule.validate({ features: {} });
const binaryOutput = wasmModule.toBinary({ log: false, write_debug_names: false });
const wasmBytes = binaryOutput.buffer;
expect(wasmBytes.length).toBeGreaterThan(0);
expect(wasmBytes.length).toBeGreaterThan(50); // Not just empty header
// 4. Instantiate with host runtime
const hostState = {
maps: new Map(),
sets: new Map(),
nextHandle: 1,
memory: null as WebAssembly.Memory | null,
};
const imports = { speckl: createHostImports(hostState) };
const wasm = await WebAssembly.instantiate(wasmBytes, imports);
const memory = wasm.instance.exports.memory as WebAssembly.Memory;
bindMemory(hostState, memory);
// 5. Verify exports
expect(typeof wasm.instance.exports.init).toBe('function');
expect(typeof wasm.instance.exports.Increment).toBe('function');
expect(typeof wasm.instance.exports.Decrement).toBe('function');
expect(typeof wasm.instance.exports.Reset).toBe('function');
expect(typeof wasm.instance.exports.GetCount).toBe('function');
expect(typeof wasm.instance.exports.getState).toBe('function');
expect(memory).toBeInstanceOf(WebAssembly.Memory);
// 6. Run init
(wasm.instance.exports.init as Function)();
// 7. Verify initial state via getState
const stateResult = (wasm.instance.exports.getState as Function)();
// getState returns i32 i32 (ptr, len)
expect(stateResult).toBeDefined();
// Read memory directly to verify state
const scalarState = readScalarState(memory, ['count', 'maxCount']);
expect(scalarState.count).toBe(0);
expect(scalarState.maxCount).toBe(10);
// 8. Run Increment 3 times, calling getState after each to sync memory
for (let i = 0; i < 3; i++) {
const ret = (wasm.instance.exports.Increment as Function)();
expect(ret).toBe(1); // Success
(wasm.instance.exports.getState as Function)(); // Sync globals to memory
}
const afterIncrement = readScalarState(memory, ['count', 'maxCount']);
expect(afterIncrement.count).toBe(3);
expect(afterIncrement.maxCount).toBe(10);
// 9. Run Decrement once
const decRet = (wasm.instance.exports.Decrement as Function)();
expect(decRet).toBe(1); // Success
(wasm.instance.exports.getState as Function)();
const afterDecrement = readScalarState(memory, ['count', 'maxCount']);
expect(afterDecrement.count).toBe(2);
// 10. Run GetCount — should return current count (global, not memory)
const getRet = (wasm.instance.exports.GetCount as Function)();
expect(getRet).toBe(2);
// 11. Run Reset
const resetRet = (wasm.instance.exports.Reset as Function)();
expect(resetRet).toBe(1); // Success
(wasm.instance.exports.getState as Function)();
const afterReset = readScalarState(memory, ['count', 'maxCount']);
expect(afterReset.count).toBe(0);
// 12. Guard test: Decrement at 0 should fail
const guardFail = (wasm.instance.exports.Decrement as Function)();
expect(guardFail).toBe(0); // Guard failed → return 0
// 13. Guard test: Increment at maxCount should fail
// First increment to max
for (let i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
(wasm.instance.exports.Increment as Function)();
}
(wasm.instance.exports.getState as Function)();
const atMax = readScalarState(memory, ['count', 'maxCount']);
expect(atMax.count).toBe(10);
const maxGuardFail = (wasm.instance.exports.Increment as Function)();
expect(maxGuardFail).toBe(0); // Guard failed → return 0
// Cleanup
fs.rmSync(tmpDir, { recursive: true, force: true });
}, 30000); // 30s timeout for wabt compilation
it('should compile TigerBeetle speck to valid WAT that wabt accepts', async () => {
// Load the full TigerBeetle speck from file
const speckPath = path.join(__dirname, 'tigerbeetle.speck');
const speckSource = fs.readFileSync(speckPath, 'utf-8');
const ast = parseSpeckContent(speckSource);
expect(ast.specks).toHaveLength(1);
expect(ast.specks[0].name).toBe('TigerBeetle');
const tmpDir = fs.mkdtempSync(path.join(os.tmpdir(), 'speckl-wasm-e2e-tb-'));
generateWASM(ast, tmpDir);
const watPath = path.join(tmpDir, 'TigerBeetle.wat');
expect(fs.existsSync(watPath)).toBe(true);
const watContent = fs.readFileSync(watPath, 'utf-8');
// Validate with wabt
const wabtModule = await loadWabt();
const wasmModule = wabtModule.parseWat('TigerBeetle.wat', watContent);
// These should not throw
wasmModule.resolveNames();
wasmModule.validate({ features: {} });
const binaryOutput = wasmModule.toBinary({ log: false, write_debug_names: false });
expect(binaryOutput.buffer.length).toBeGreaterThan(100);
// Cleanup
fs.rmSync(tmpDir, { recursive: true, force: true });
}, 30000);
});

View file

@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
import { describe, it, expect } from 'vitest';
import { parseSpeckContent, parseSpeckFile } from '../src/parser.js';
import { generateWASM } from '../src/generators/wasm.js';
describe('SpeckDL Parser', () => {
describe('parseSpeckContent', () => {
@ -526,75 +525,5 @@ speck Second {
});
});
describe('WASM Codegen', () => {
it('should generate WAT for TigerBeetle with all exports', () => {
const ast = parseSpeckFile('./__tests__/tigerbeetle.speck');
const fs = require('fs');
const os = require('os');
const path = require('path');
const tmpDir = fs.mkdtempSync(path.join(os.tmpdir(), 'speckl-wasm-test-'));
generateWASM(ast, tmpDir);
const watPath = path.join(tmpDir, 'TigerBeetle.wat');
expect(fs.existsSync(watPath)).toBe(true);
const wat = fs.readFileSync(watPath, 'utf-8');
// Module structure
expect(wat).toContain('(module');
expect(wat).toContain('(memory (export "memory")');
// Host imports
expect(wat).toContain('(import "speckl" "map_create"');
expect(wat).toContain('(import "speckl" "set_create"');
// State globals
expect(wat).toContain('(global $nextId');
expect(wat).toContain('(global $accounts');
expect(wat).toContain('(global $transfers');
expect(wat).toContain('(global $ledgerOpen');
// init export
expect(wat).toContain('(func $init (export "init")');
// Action exports
expect(wat).toContain('(func $CreateAccount (export "CreateAccount")');
expect(wat).toContain('(func $Transfer (export "Transfer")');
expect(wat).toContain('(func $CloseAccount (export "CloseAccount")');
expect(wat).toContain('(func $CloseLedger (export "CloseLedger")');
// getState export
expect(wat).toContain('(func $getState (export "getState")');
// Constraint stub
expect(wat).toContain('(func $checkConstraints (export "checkConstraints")');
// Scalar init values
expect(wat).toContain('(i32.const 1)'); // nextId default
expect(wat).toContain('(call $map_create)');
expect(wat).toContain('(call $set_create)');
fs.rmSync(tmpDir, { recursive: true });
});
it('should emit scalar guard expressions as WASM comparison', () => {
const ast = parseSpeckFile('./__tests__/tigerbeetle.speck');
const fs = require('fs');
const os = require('os');
const path = require('path');
const tmpDir = fs.mkdtempSync(path.join(os.tmpdir(), 'speckl-wasm-test-'));
generateWASM(ast, tmpDir);
const wat = fs.readFileSync(path.join(tmpDir, 'TigerBeetle.wat'), 'utf-8');
// ledgerOpen == true should compile to i32.eq
expect(wat).toContain('(i32.eq (global.get $ledgerOpen) (i32.const 1))');
// nextId + 1 should compile to i32.add
expect(wat).toContain('(i32.add (global.get $nextId) (i32.const 1))');
fs.rmSync(tmpDir, { recursive: true });
});
});
});

View file

@ -1 +1 @@
{"version":"2.1.9","results":[[":__tests__/parser.test.ts",{"duration":40.638667,"failed":false}],[":__tests__/e2e-wasm.test.ts",{"duration":25.08648199999999,"failed":true}],[":src/__tests__/compiler.test.ts",{"duration":13.108581000000015,"failed":false}]]}
{"version":"2.1.9","results":[[":__tests__/parser.test.ts",{"duration":37.17850800000002,"failed":false}],[":src/__tests__/compiler.test.ts",{"duration":10.335649000000046,"failed":false}]]}

View file

@ -305,7 +305,7 @@ function rewriteExpr(expr: string, stateVarNames: Set<string>, localNames: Set<s
// Step 2: Replace state enum literals with enum refs BEFORE identifier replacement
const allStateValues = new Set<string>(knownStateValues);
// Add common fallback states
['Open','Grooming','Groomed','Assigned','InProgress','InReview','Merged','Blocked','Closed','Idle','Parsing','Parsed','ProvenanceGenerated','BOMsGenerated','TypeScriptGenerated','WASMGenerated','Done'].forEach(s => allStateValues.add(s));
['Open','Grooming','Groomed','Assigned','InProgress','InReview','Merged','Blocked','Closed','Idle','Parsing','Parsed','ProvenanceGenerated','BOMsGenerated','TypeScriptGenerated','Done'].forEach(s => allStateValues.add(s));
if (allStateValues.size > 0) {
const stateValueRegex = new RegExp('\\b(' + Array.from(allStateValues).join('|') + ')\\b', 'g');
ts = ts.replace(stateValueRegex, `${stateEnumName}.$1`);
@ -361,7 +361,7 @@ function cleanName(s: string): string {
function replaceStateWithEnum(expr: string, enumName: string, knownStateValues: string[]): string {
const allStateValues = new Set<string>(knownStateValues);
['Open','Grooming','Groomed','Assigned','InProgress','InReview','Merged','Blocked','Closed','Idle','Parsing','Parsed','ProvenanceGenerated','BOMsGenerated','TypeScriptGenerated','WASMGenerated','Done'].forEach(s => allStateValues.add(s));
['Open','Grooming','Groomed','Assigned','InProgress','InReview','Merged','Blocked','Closed','Idle','Parsing','Parsed','ProvenanceGenerated','BOMsGenerated','TypeScriptGenerated','Done'].forEach(s => allStateValues.add(s));
if (allStateValues.size === 0) return expr;
const stateValueRegex = new RegExp('\\b(' + Array.from(allStateValues).join('|') + ')\\b', 'g');
return expr.replace(stateValueRegex, `${enumName}.$1`);

View file

@ -1,472 +0,0 @@
import { AST, SpeckNode, StateNode, InitNode, ActionNode, EventNode } from '../parser.js';
import fs from 'fs';
import path from 'path';
/**
* Generate WebAssembly Text (WAT) from a SpeckDL state machine spec.
*
* Emits a .wat file per speck with:
* - Linear memory for scalar state (Nat/Int/Real/Bool)
* - Imported host functions for Map<K,V> and Set<T>
* - Exported `init()` — calls host to init Maps/Sets + sets scalars
* - Exported action functions (one per action)
* - Exported `getState()` — serializes scalars into memory
* - Exported `checkConstraints()` — runtime guard stubs
*
* Compile to .wasm with: wat2wasm <file>.wat -o <file>.wasm
*
* Host runtime (JS): see `speckl/runtime/wasm-host.js`
*/
// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
// Host imports required by generated modules
// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
const HOST_IMPORTS = [
'(import "speckl" "map_create" (func $map_create (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "map_set" (func $map_set (param i32 i32 i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "map_get" (func $map_get (param i32 i32) (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "map_has" (func $map_has (param i32 i32) (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "map_remove" (func $map_remove (param i32 i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "set_create" (func $set_create (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "set_add" (func $set_add (param i32 i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "set_has" (func $set_has (param i32 i32) (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "set_size" (func $set_size (param i32) (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "alloc" (func $alloc (param i32) (result i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "write_i32" (func $write_i32 (param i32 i32)))',
'(import "speckl" "write_f64" (func $write_f64 (param i32 f64)))',
];
export function generateWASM(ast: AST, outputDir: string): void {
for (const speck of ast.specks) {
const hasStateMachine = speck.members.some(m =>
m.type === 'state' || m.type === 'init' || m.type === 'action'
);
if (!hasStateMachine) continue;
const wat = emitSpeckWAT(speck);
const filename = `${speck.name}.wat`;
const filepath = path.join(outputDir, filename);
fs.writeFileSync(filepath, wat);
console.log(`Generated WAT: ${filepath}`);
}
}
function emitSpeckWAT(speck: SpeckNode): string {
const stateNode = speck.members.find(m => m.type === 'state') as StateNode | undefined;
const initNode = speck.members.find(m => m.type === 'init') as InitNode | undefined;
const actions = speck.members.filter(m => m.type === 'action') as ActionNode[];
const events = speck.members.filter(m => m.type === 'event') as EventNode[];
const stateVars = stateNode?.variables ?? [];
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 1. Memory layout for scalar state variables
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// Each scalar gets 8 bytes (i64/f64 slot). Map/Set handles are i32 refs
// stored in globals.
//
// Layout: [0..8) var0, [8..16) var1, ... then string pool for getState()
//
const scalarVars = stateVars.filter(v => isScalarType(v.typeExpr));
const refVars = stateVars.filter(v => !isScalarType(v.typeExpr));
const memSize = Math.max(1, Math.ceil((scalarVars.length * 8 + 1024) / 65536));
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 2. Globals: one per state variable
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
const globals = stateVars.map((v, i) => {
if (isScalarType(v.typeExpr)) {
const wasmType = wasmTypeOf(v.typeExpr);
const initVal = initValueFor(v.name, v.typeExpr, v.defaultInit, initNode);
return `(global $${v.name} (mut ${wasmType}) (${wasmType}.const ${initVal}))`;
} else {
// Map or Set — store as i32 handle (0 = uninitialized)
return `(global $${v.name} (mut i32) (i32.const 0))`;
}
}).join('\n');
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 3. init() export
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
const initBody = emitInitBody(stateVars, initNode);
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 4. Action exports
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
const actionFuncs = actions.map(a => emitActionWAT(a, stateVars)).join('\n\n');
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 5. getState() export — write scalars to memory, return ptr+len
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
const getStateBody = emitGetState(scalarVars);
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 6. checkConstraints() stub
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
const checkConstraints = `
;; checkConstraints — runtime constraint evaluation stub
(func $checkConstraints (export "checkConstraints") (result i32)
;; TODO: evaluate constraint expressions at runtime
(i32.const 1)
)`;
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
// 7. Assemble module
// -------------------------------------------------------------------------
const module =
`;; Auto-generated by speckl-compile from ${speck.name}\n` +
`;; Compile: wat2wasm ${speck.name}.wat -o ${speck.name}.wasm\n\n` +
`(module\n` +
` ;; Host imports for Map/Set/alloc\n` +
` ${HOST_IMPORTS.join('\n ')}\n\n` +
` ;; Linear memory (exported so host can read state)\n` +
` (memory (export "memory") ${memSize})\n\n` +
` ;; State globals\n` +
` ${globals}\n\n` +
` ;; ---- init ----\n` +
` (func $init (export "init")\n` +
` ${initBody}\n` +
` )\n\n` +
` ;; ---- Actions ----\n` +
` ${actionFuncs}\n\n` +
` ;; ---- getState ----\n` +
` (func $getState (export "getState") (result i32 i32)\n` +
` ${getStateBody}\n` +
` )\n\n` +
` ${checkConstraints}\n` +
`)`;
return module;
}
// =============================================================================
// init() body generation
// =============================================================================
function emitInitBody(
stateVars: StateNode['variables'],
initNode: InitNode | undefined
): string {
const lines: string[] = [];
for (const v of stateVars) {
if (isScalarType(v.typeExpr)) {
const val = initValueFor(v.name, v.typeExpr, v.defaultInit, initNode);
const wasmType = wasmTypeOf(v.typeExpr);
lines.push(`(${wasmType}.const ${val})`);
lines.push(`(global.set $${v.name})`);
} else if (isMapType(v.typeExpr)) {
lines.push(`(call $map_create)`);
lines.push(`(global.set $${v.name})`);
} else if (isSetType(v.typeExpr)) {
lines.push(`(call $set_create)`);
lines.push(`(global.set $${v.name})`);
}
}
return lines.join('\n ');
}
// =============================================================================
// Action function generation
// =============================================================================
function emitActionWAT(action: ActionNode, stateVars: StateNode['variables']): string {
const scalarStateNames = new Set(
stateVars.filter(v => isScalarType(v.typeExpr)).map(v => v.name)
);
const mapStateNames = new Set(
stateVars.filter(v => isMapType(v.typeExpr)).map(v => v.name)
);
const setStateNames = new Set(
stateVars.filter(v => isSetType(v.typeExpr)).map(v => v.name)
);
// Params: SpeckDL Nat/Int → i32, Real → f64, Bool → i32
const params = action.params.map(p => {
const t = wasmTypeOf(p.type);
return `(param $${p.name} ${t})`;
}).join(' ');
const localLines: string[] = [];
const bodyLines: string[] = [];
for (const stmt of action.statements) {
switch (stmt.type) {
case 'require': {
// Emit guard: if !condition → return 0 (failure indicator)
// For now, require guards that reference only scalar state variables
// and simple comparisons are emitted. Complex ones trap/return 0.
const guard = emitGuardExpr(stmt.expr, scalarStateNames, mapStateNames, setStateNames);
bodyLines.push(`;; require: ${stmt.expr}`);
bodyLines.push(guard);
break;
}
case 'assign': {
bodyLines.push(`;; ${stmt.target} := ${stmt.expr}`);
bodyLines.push(emitAssignment(stmt.target, stmt.expr, scalarStateNames, mapStateNames));
break;
}
case 'let': {
// let name := expr — allocate local, compute expr, store
const wasmT = inferExprType(stmt.expr, scalarStateNames);
localLines.push(`(local $${stmt.name} ${wasmT})`);
bodyLines.push(emitExpr(stmt.expr, scalarStateNames));
bodyLines.push(`(local.set $${stmt.name})`);
break;
}
case 'emit': {
// emit → decision log push (host call stub for now)
bodyLines.push(`;; emit ${stmt.event} { ... }`);
// TODO: structured emit via host
break;
}
case 'return': {
bodyLines.push(emitExpr(stmt.expr, scalarStateNames));
bodyLines.push(`(return)`);
break;
}
}
}
// Default return: i32.const 1 for success if action returns void
const hasReturn = action.statements.some(s => s.type === 'return');
if (!hasReturn) {
bodyLines.push(`(i32.const 1)`);
}
const locals = localLines.length ? `\n ${localLines.join('\n ')}` : '';
return ` ;; action: ${action.name}\n` +
` (func $${action.name} (export "${action.name}") ${params} (result i32)\n` +
` ${locals}\n` +
` ${bodyLines.join('\n ')}\n` +
` )`;
}
// =============================================================================
// Expression / guard emission (simplified — covers common scalar patterns)
// =============================================================================
function emitGuardExpr(
expr: string,
scalars: Set<string>,
maps: Set<string>,
sets: Set<string>
): string {
// Very simple pattern: "x >= 0", "x == true", "x != y", etc.
const m = expr.match(/^\s*(\w+)\s*(>=|<=|>|<|==|!=)\s*(.+?)\s*$/);
if (!m) {
// Can't compile guard — just comment, no stack effect
return `;; Complex guard not compiled: ${expr}`;
}
const [, left, op, rightRaw] = m;
const right = rightRaw.trim();
if (!scalars.has(left)) {
return `;; Guard on non-scalar not compiled: ${expr}`;
}
const lhs = `(global.get $${left})`;
// Parse right side
let rhs: string;
const rightNum = parseFloat(right);
if (!isNaN(rightNum)) {
rhs = `(i32.const ${rightNum})`;
} else if (right === 'true') {
rhs = `(i32.const 1)`;
} else if (right === 'false') {
rhs = `(i32.const 0)`;
} else if (scalars.has(right)) {
rhs = `(global.get $${right})`;
} else {
return `;; Complex right-hand side not compiled: ${expr}`;
}
const comparison = (() => {
switch (op) {
case '>=': return `(i32.ge_s ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '<=': return `(i32.le_s ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '>': return `(i32.gt_s ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '<': return `(i32.lt_s ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '==': return `(i32.eq ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '!=': return `(i32.ne ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
default: return `(i32.const 1)`;
}
})();
// If guard fails (comparison is FALSE), return 0
return `${comparison}\n (i32.eqz)\n (if (then (return (i32.const 0))))`;
}
function emitExpr(expr: string, scalars: Set<string>): string {
// Handle: nextId + 1, nextId, numeric literals, etc.
expr = expr.trim();
// Simple numeric literal
const num = parseFloat(expr);
if (!isNaN(num) && !expr.match(/\w/)) {
return `(i32.const ${num})`;
}
// Simple variable reference
if (/^\w+$/.test(expr) && scalars.has(expr)) {
return `(global.get $${expr})`;
}
// Binary op: left + right, left - right, left * right
const binOp = expr.match(/^(\w+)\s*([+\-*/])\s*(.+)$/);
if (binOp) {
const [, left, op, right] = binOp;
const lhs = scalars.has(left) ? `(global.get $${left})` : `(i32.const ${parseFloat(left)})`;
const rhsNum = parseFloat(right.trim());
const rhs = isNaN(rhsNum)
? (scalars.has(right.trim()) ? `(global.get $${right.trim()})` : `(i32.const 0) ;; uncompiled`)
: `(i32.const ${rhsNum})`;
switch (op) {
case '+': return `(i32.add ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '-': return `(i32.sub ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
case '*': return `(i32.mul ${lhs} ${rhs})`;
default: return `(i32.const 0) ;; uncompiled op ${op}`;
}
}
return `(i32.const 0) ;; uncompiled expr: ${expr}`;
}
function inferExprType(expr: string, scalars: Set<string>): string {
// Default to i32; we could infer from variable types but that's future work
return 'i32';
}
function emitAssignment(
target: string,
expr: string,
scalars: Set<string>,
maps: Set<string>
): string {
// Scalar assignment: this.x = expr
if (scalars.has(target)) {
return `${emitExpr(expr, scalars)}\n (global.set $${target})`;
}
// Map assignment: accounts[id] := expr — host call
const mapAssign = target.match(/^(\w+)\[(.+)\]$/);
if (mapAssign && maps.has(mapAssign[1])) {
const mapName = mapAssign[1];
const keyExpr = mapAssign[2];
// For now: map_set(map_handle, key_handle, value_handle)
// This needs boxing; simplified version just marks as stub
return `;; Map assignment not yet compiled: ${target} := ${expr}`;
}
// Record field assignment: accounts[id].field := expr
const recordAssign = target.match(/^(\w+)\[(.+)\]\.(\w+)$/);
if (recordAssign && maps.has(recordAssign[1])) {
return `;; Record field assignment not yet compiled: ${target} := ${expr}`;
}
return `;; Unrecognized assignment target: ${target}`;
}
// =============================================================================
// getState() — serialize scalar state to memory
// =============================================================================
function emitGetState(scalarVars: StateNode['variables']): string {
const lines: string[] = [];
let offset = 0;
for (const v of scalarVars) {
const t = wasmTypeOf(v.typeExpr);
if (t === 'i32') {
lines.push(`(i32.const ${offset})`);
lines.push(`(global.get $${v.name})`);
lines.push(`(i32.store)`);
offset += 4;
} else if (t === 'f64') {
lines.push(`(i32.const ${offset})`);
lines.push(`(global.get $${v.name})`);
lines.push(`(f64.store)`);
offset += 8;
} else {
// i64
lines.push(`(i32.const ${offset})`);
lines.push(`(global.get $${v.name})`);
lines.push(`(i64.store)`);
offset += 8;
}
}
// Return (ptr, len)
lines.push(`(i32.const 0)`); // ptr = 0
lines.push(`(i32.const ${offset})`); // len = total bytes written
return lines.join('\n ');
}
// =============================================================================
// Type helpers
// =============================================================================
function isScalarType(t: any): boolean {
if (t.type === 'primitive') {
return ['Nat', 'Int', 'Real', 'Bool'].includes(t.name);
}
if (t.type === 'ident') return true; // opaque ident → i32 handle
return false;
}
function isMapType(t: any): boolean {
return t.type === 'map';
}
function isSetType(t: any): boolean {
return t.type === 'set';
}
function wasmTypeOf(t: any): string {
if (t.type === 'primitive') {
if (t.name === 'Nat') return 'i32';
if (t.name === 'Int') return 'i32';
if (t.name === 'Real') return 'f64';
if (t.name === 'Bool') return 'i32';
if (t.name === 'String') return 'i32'; // ptr
if (t.name === 'Bytes') return 'i32'; // ptr
return 'i32';
}
if (t.type === 'ident') return 'i32';
if (t.type === 'map') return 'i32'; // handle
if (t.type === 'set') return 'i32'; // handle
return 'i32';
}
function initValueFor(
varName: string,
typeExpr: any,
defaultInit: string | undefined,
initNode: InitNode | undefined
): string {
// Use initNode assignment if present
const initAssign = initNode?.assignments.find(a => a.name === varName);
if (initAssign) {
const expr = initAssign.expr.trim();
if (expr === 'true') return '1';
if (expr === 'false') return '0';
if (expr === 'Map.empty()') return '0'; // will be replaced by host call
if (expr === 'Set.empty()') return '0';
const num = parseFloat(expr);
if (!isNaN(num)) return String(num);
return '0';
}
// Fallback to defaultInit
if (defaultInit) {
if (defaultInit === 'true') return '1';
if (defaultInit === 'false') return '0';
const num = parseFloat(defaultInit);
if (!isNaN(num)) return String(num);
}
// Default zero
if (typeExpr.type === 'primitive' && typeExpr.name === 'Real') return '0.0';
return '0';
}

View file

@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ import { generateProvenanceGraph } from './generators/provenance.js';
import { generateCycloneDX } from './generators/cyclonedx.js';
import { generateSPDX } from './generators/spdx.js';
import { generateTypeScriptStateMachine } from './generators/typescript-state-machine.js';
import { generateWASM } from './generators/wasm.js';
import fs from 'fs';
import path from 'path';
@ -82,9 +82,6 @@ async function main() {
console.log('\nGenerating TypeScript state machine...');
generateTypeScriptStateMachine(ast, options.outputDir);
// Generate WASM state machine
console.log('\nGenerating WebAssembly (WAT)...');
generateWASM(ast, options.outputDir);
// Generate BOM based on format selection
if (options.bomFormat === 'cdx' || options.bomFormat === 'both') {

View file

@ -1,165 +0,0 @@
/**
* Speckl WASM Host Runtime
*
* Provides JS-side implementations for imported host functions used by
* Speckl-generated WASM modules:
* - map_create, map_set, map_get, map_has, map_remove
* - set_create, set_add, set_has, set_size
* - alloc, write_i32, write_f64
*
* Usage:
* const wasmModule = await WebAssembly.instantiate(bytes, {
* speckl: createHostImports()
* });
* wasmModule.exports.init();
* wasmModule.exports.CreateAccount(100.0);
* const state = getStateFromMemory(wasmModule);
*/
interface HostState {
maps: Map<number, Map<number, any>>;
sets: Map<number, Set<any>>;
nextHandle: number;
memory: WebAssembly.Memory | null;
}
function createHostState(): HostState {
return {
maps: new Map(),
sets: new Map(),
nextHandle: 1,
memory: null,
};
}
export function createHostImports(state: HostState = createHostState()) {
return {
// ---- Map operations ----
map_create: (): number => {
const handle = state.nextHandle++;
state.maps.set(handle, new Map());
return handle;
},
map_set: (mapHandle: number, keyHandle: number, valueHandle: number): void => {
const map = state.maps.get(mapHandle);
if (!map) throw new Error(`Map handle ${mapHandle} not found`);
// For now, keys and values are simple i32 handles; boxing layer comes later
map.set(keyHandle, valueHandle);
},
map_get: (mapHandle: number, keyHandle: number): number => {
const map = state.maps.get(mapHandle);
if (!map) return 0;
return map.has(keyHandle) ? (map.get(keyHandle) ?? 0) : 0;
},
map_has: (mapHandle: number, keyHandle: number): number => {
const map = state.maps.get(mapHandle);
if (!map) return 0;
return map.has(keyHandle) ? 1 : 0;
},
map_remove: (mapHandle: number, keyHandle: number): void => {
const map = state.maps.get(mapHandle);
if (map) map.delete(keyHandle);
},
// ---- Set operations ----
set_create: (): number => {
const handle = state.nextHandle++;
state.sets.set(handle, new Set());
return handle;
},
set_add: (setHandle: number, valueHandle: number): void => {
const set = state.sets.get(setHandle);
if (!set) throw new Error(`Set handle ${setHandle} not found`);
set.add(valueHandle);
},
set_has: (setHandle: number, valueHandle: number): number => {
const set = state.sets.get(setHandle);
if (!set) return 0;
return set.has(valueHandle) ? 1 : 0;
},
set_size: (setHandle: number): number => {
const set = state.sets.get(setHandle);
if (!set) return 0;
return set.size;
},
// ---- Memory helpers ----
alloc: (size: number): number => {
// Simple bump allocator: for now, just return 0 (stack allocation handled by compiler)
// Future: maintain bump pointer in memory
return 0;
},
write_i32: (ptr: number, value: number): void => {
if (!state.memory) throw new Error('Memory not bound');
const view = new DataView(state.memory.buffer);
view.setInt32(ptr, value, true); // little-endian
},
write_f64: (ptr: number, value: number): void => {
if (!state.memory) throw new Error('Memory not bound');
const view = new DataView(state.memory.buffer);
view.setFloat64(ptr, value, true);
},
};
}
/**
* Bind a WASM memory export to the host state so write_i32/write_f64 work.
*/
export function bindMemory(state: HostState, memory: WebAssembly.Memory): void {
state.memory = memory;
}
/**
* Read scalar state from WASM memory after getState() has been called.
* Layout matches emitGetState(): [nextId: i32][ledgerOpen: i32]...
*/
export function readScalarState(memory: WebAssembly.Memory, varNames: string[]): Record<string, number> {
const view = new DataView(memory.buffer);
const result: Record<string, number> = {};
let offset = 0;
for (const name of varNames) {
// All current scalars are i32 in TigerBeetle; extend for f64 later
result[name] = view.getInt32(offset, true);
offset += 4;
}
return result;
}
/**
* High-level helper: instantiate a Speckl WASM module from WAT text.
* Requires `wat2wasm` or a WAT parser. For now, expects pre-compiled .wasm bytes.
*/
export async function instantiateSpeckl(
wasmBytes: BufferSource,
varNames: string[]
): Promise<{
exports: WebAssembly.Exports;
state: HostState;
getScalarState: () => Record<string, number>;
}> {
const hostState = createHostState();
const imports = { speckl: createHostImports(hostState) };
const wasm = await WebAssembly.instantiate(wasmBytes, imports);
const memory = wasm.instance.exports.memory as WebAssembly.Memory;
bindMemory(hostState, memory);
const getScalarState = () => readScalarState(memory, varNames);
return {
exports: wasm.instance.exports,
state: hostState,
getScalarState,
};
}

View file

@ -12,7 +12,7 @@
"@type": "prov:Generation",
"prov:activity": {
"@type": "prov:Activity",
"prov:startTime": "2026-05-05T10:11:33.422Z"
"prov:startTime": "2026-05-10T05:02:58.864Z"
}
},
"rdfs:label": "RetryHandler",

View file

@ -38,7 +38,7 @@
"name": "Scott Scoble",
"email": "scott@scoble.me"
},
"timestamp": "2026-05-05T10:11:33.425Z"
"timestamp": "2026-05-10T05:02:58.867Z"
},
{
"subject": "speck:RetryHandler",
@ -53,7 +53,7 @@
"name": "Speckl Compiler",
"email": "compiler@speckl.scoble.me"
},
"timestamp": "2026-05-05T10:11:33.425Z"
"timestamp": "2026-05-10T05:02:58.867Z"
},
{
"subject": "speck:RetryHandler",
@ -68,7 +68,7 @@
"name": "Speckl Compiler",
"email": "compiler@speckl.scoble.me"
},
"timestamp": "2026-05-05T10:11:33.425Z"
"timestamp": "2026-05-10T05:02:58.867Z"
}
]
}

View file

@ -13,7 +13,7 @@
"spdxVersion": "3.0.1",
"dataLicense": "CC0-1.0",
"creationInfo": {
"created": "2026-05-05T10:11:33.426Z",
"created": "2026-05-10T05:02:58.868Z",
"createdBy": [
"Organization: Speckl",
"tool: speckl-compile-0.2.0"
@ -27,7 +27,7 @@
"@type": "spdx:Tool",
"name": "speckl-compile"
},
"timestamp": "2026-05-05T10:11:33.426Z",
"timestamp": "2026-05-10T05:02:58.868Z",
"comment": "Review type: manual"
}
]

131
examples/Paxos.speck Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,131 @@
speck Paxos {
// Classic Paxos consensus protocol ported from TLA+ to SpeckDL v0.3
// Demonstrates multi-role state machines, ballot numbers, quorums,
// and safety invariants (at most one value chosen per slot).
// Adapted from Lamport's "The Part-Time Parliament" and TLA+ Paxos spec.
state {
// Ballot number → (value, proposer) — for each slot
ballots: Map(Ballot, Proposal)
// Acceptor state: which ballot each acceptor has promised for each slot
promises: Map(AcceptorSlot, Ballot)
// Acceptor state: last vote cast (if any) for each slot
lastVote: Map(AcceptorSlot, Ballot)
// Value voted for (if any) for each slot
votedValue: Map(AcceptorSlot, String)
// Set of acceptors
acceptors: Set(String)
// Quorum size (simple majority)
quorum: Map(String, Set(String))
// Chosen values: ballot → value (finalized)
chosen: Map(Ballot, String)
}
init {
let q := {"a1", "a2", "a3"}
acceptors == q
ballots == emptyMap
promises == emptyMap
lastVote == emptyMap
votedValue == emptyMap
chosen == emptyMap
quorum == emptyMap
}
invariant BallotUniqueness {
forall b in ballots.keys:
forall b2 in ballots.keys \ {b}:
b.number != b2.number
}
// Safety: at most one value per ballot
invariant SingleValuePerBallot {
forall b in ballots.keys:
forall b2 in ballots.keys:
b.number == b2.number implies ballots[b].value == ballots[b2].value
}
// Safety: if a value is chosen, no other value for that ballot
invariant PaxosSafety {
forall b in chosen.keys:
forall b2 in ballots.keys:
b2.number == b.number implies ballots[b2].value == chosen[b]
}
// Phase 1a: Proposer sends Prepare with ballot number
action ProposerPrepare(prop: String, bnum: Nat) {
require bnum > 0
let b := { number: bnum, value: null, proposer: prop }
ballots[b] := { number: bnum, value: null, proposer: prop }
emit PrepareSent { ballot: bnum, proposer: prop }
}
// Phase 1b: Acceptor receives Prepare, promises if ballot > last promised
action AcceptorPromise(acc: String, ballot: Nat) {
require acc in acceptors
let acSlot := { acceptor: acc, slot: 1 }
let curPromise := if acSlot in promises.keys: promises[acSlot].number else 0
require ballot > curPromise
promises[acSlot] := { number: ballot, value: null, proposer: null }
let prevVote := if acSlot in lastVote.keys: lastVote[acSlot] else { number: 0, value: null, proposer: null }
emit PromiseSent {
acceptor: acc,
ballot: ballot,
lastVoteBallot: prevVote.number,
lastVoteValue: if prevVote.number > 0: votedValue[acSlot] else null
}
}
// Phase 2a: Proposer collects quorum of promises, proposes value
action ProposerPropose(prop: String, ballot: Nat, value: String) {
require ballots[{ number: ballot, value: null, proposer: prop }] != null
require ballots[{ number: ballot, value: null, proposer: prop }].proposer == prop
ballots[{ number: ballot, value: null, proposer: prop }] :=
{ number: ballot, value: value, proposer: prop }
emit ProposalSent { ballot: ballot, value: value, proposer: prop }
}
// Phase 2b: Acceptor votes for proposal if ballot >= last promised
action AcceptorVote(acc: String, ballot: Nat, value: String) {
require acc in acceptors
let acSlot := { acceptor: acc, slot: 1 }
require acSlot in promises.keys
require promises[acSlot].number == ballot
let prevVote := if acSlot in lastVote.keys: lastVote[acSlot].number else 0
require ballot >= prevVote
lastVote[acSlot] := { number: ballot, value: value, proposer: null }
votedValue[acSlot] := value
emit VotedSent { acceptor: acc, ballot: ballot, value: value }
}
// Learn: value is chosen when a quorum of acceptors has voted
action LearnerDecide(ballot: Nat, value: String) {
require { number: ballot, value: value, proposer: null } notIn chosen.keys
chosen[{ number: ballot, value: value, proposer: null }] := value
emit Chosen { ballot: ballot, value: value }
}
next:
ProposerPrepare
| AcceptorPromise
| ProposerPropose
| AcceptorVote
| LearnerDecide
}

View file

@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
speck PreconditionTest {
state: {
balance: Integer
active: Boolean
}
action SetBalance(newBalance: Integer) {
precondition: newBalance >= 0
postcondition: this.balance == newBalance
require newBalance >= 0
this.balance := newBalance
}
action Deactivate() {
precondition: this.balance == 0
or this.active == false
postcondition: this.active == false
this.active := false
}
}

272
examples/Raft.speck Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,272 @@
speck Raft {
// Raft consensus protocol ported to SpeckDL v0.3
// Demonstrates leader election, log replication, commitment, and safety.
// Based on Ongaro & Ousterhout's "In Search of an Understandable Consensus Algorithm" (2014).
// Natural bridge from Paxos (academic) → TigerBeetle (production replicated state machine).
type LogIndex = Nat
type Term = Nat
type ServerId = String
type LogEntry = {
term: Term,
index: LogIndex,
command: String
}
type ServerState = {
role: String, // "follower", "candidate", "leader"
currentTerm: Term,
votedFor: String | null,
log: List(LogEntry),
commitIndex: LogIndex,
lastApplied: LogIndex
}
type AppendEntriesReq = {
term: Term,
leaderId: ServerId,
prevLogIndex: LogIndex,
prevLogTerm: Term,
entries: List(LogEntry),
leaderCommit: LogIndex
}
type RequestVoteReq = {
term: Term,
candidateId: ServerId,
lastLogIndex: LogIndex,
lastLogTerm: Term
}
state {
servers: Set(ServerId)
serverState: Map(ServerId, ServerState)
// Leader-specific: for each server, track nextIndex and matchIndex
nextIndex: Map(Map(ServerId, ServerId), LogIndex)
matchIndex: Map(Map(ServerId, ServerId), LogIndex)
// Election timer (abstracted as random timeout)
electionTimeout: Map(ServerId, Nat)
}
init {
servers == {"s1", "s2", "s3", "s4", "s5"}
// All servers start as followers in term 0
forall s in servers:
serverState[s] == {
role: "follower",
currentTerm: 0,
votedFor: null,
log: List.empty,
commitIndex: 0,
lastApplied: 0
}
nextIndex == emptyMap
matchIndex == emptyMap
electionTimeout == emptyMap
}
// Safety: Election Safety — at most one leader per term
invariant SingleLeaderPerTerm {
forall s1 in servers:
forall s2 in servers:
serverState[s1].role == "leader" and
serverState[s2].role == "leader" and
s1 != s2 implies
serverState[s1].currentTerm != serverState[s2].currentTerm
}
// Safety: Leader Completeness — committed entries survive elections
invariant LeaderCompleteness {
forall s in servers:
serverState[s].role == "leader" implies
forall entry in serverState[s].log:
entry.index <= serverState[s].commitIndex implies
entry.term <= serverState[s].currentTerm
}
// Safety: Log Matching — if two logs have same term at same index, entries match
invariant LogMatching {
forall s1 in servers:
forall s2 in servers:
forall i in [1 .. length(serverState[s1].log)]:
i <= length(serverState[s2].log) and
serverState[s1].log[i].term == serverState[s2].log[i].term implies
serverState[s1].log[i].command == serverState[s2].log[i].command
}
// Start election: follower times out, becomes candidate
action StartElection(server: ServerId) {
require server in servers
require serverState[server].role == "follower"
let newTerm := serverState[server].currentTerm + 1
// Increment term, vote for self
serverState[server].currentTerm := newTerm
serverState[server].role := "candidate"
serverState[server].votedFor := server
emit ElectionStarted { server: server, term: newTerm }
}
// Grant vote: follower votes for candidate if candidate's log is at least as up-to-date
action GrantVote(voter: ServerId, req: RequestVoteReq) {
require voter in servers
require serverState[voter].role == "follower" or
serverState[voter].role == "candidate"
// Only vote if candidate's term >= our term
require req.term >= serverState[voter].currentTerm
// If candidate's term > ours, step down
if req.term > serverState[voter].currentTerm {
serverState[voter].currentTerm := req.term
serverState[voter].role := "follower"
serverState[voter].votedFor := null
}
// Check not already voted in this term
require serverState[voter].votedFor == null or
serverState[voter].votedFor == req.candidateId
// Candidate log must be at least as complete as ours
let voterLog := serverState[voter].log
let voterLastIndex := length(voterLog)
let voterLastTerm := if voterLastIndex > 0: voterLog[voterLastIndex].term else 0
require req.lastLogTerm > voterLastTerm or
(req.lastLogTerm == voterLastTerm and req.lastLogIndex >= voterLastIndex)
serverState[voter].votedFor := req.candidateId
emit VoteGranted { voter: voter, candidate: req.candidateId, term: req.term }
}
// Become leader: candidate receives majority of votes
action BecomeLeader(server: ServerId) {
require server in servers
require serverState[server].role == "candidate"
// Count votes received (simplified: assumes quorum reached via external counting)
serverState[server].role := "leader"
// Initialize nextIndex/matchIndex for all other servers
forall s in servers \ {server}:
let lastLogIndex := length(serverState[server].log)
nextIndex[{ leader: server, follower: s }] := lastLogIndex + 1
matchIndex[{ leader: server, follower: s }] := 0
emit LeaderElected { leader: server, term: serverState[server].currentTerm }
// Send initial empty AppendEntries (heartbeat) to assert leadership
emit HeartbeatSent { leader: server, term: serverState[server].currentTerm }
}
// Append entries: leader replicates log entry to followers
action AppendEntries(leader: ServerId, follower: ServerId, req: AppendEntriesReq) {
require leader in servers
require follower in servers
require leader != follower
require serverState[leader].role == "leader"
// Verify term consistency
let followerTerm := serverState[follower].currentTerm
require req.term >= followerTerm
// If leader's term is stale, step down
if req.term > serverState[leader].currentTerm {
serverState[leader].currentTerm := req.term
serverState[leader].role := "follower"
serverState[leader].votedFor := null
return
}
// Update follower's term if behind
if req.term > followerTerm {
serverState[follower].currentTerm := req.term
serverState[follower].role := "follower"
serverState[follower].votedFor := null
}
// Check log consistency at prevLogIndex
let fLog := serverState[follower].log
require req.prevLogIndex == 0 or
(req.prevLogIndex <= length(fLog) and
fLog[req.prevLogIndex].term == req.prevLogTerm)
// Delete conflicting entries, append new ones
let truncated := if req.prevLogIndex < length(fLog):
take(fLog, req.prevLogIndex)
else fLog
serverState[follower].log := concat(truncated, req.entries)
// Update commit index
if req.leaderCommit > serverState[follower].commitIndex {
let lastNewEntry := req.prevLogIndex + length(req.entries)
serverState[follower].commitIndex :=
if req.leaderCommit < lastNewEntry: req.leaderCommit else lastNewEntry
}
emit EntriesReplicated {
leader: leader,
follower: follower,
entries: length(req.entries)
}
}
// Advance commit index: leader commits when majority replicated
action AdvanceCommit(leader: ServerId) {
require leader in servers
require serverState[leader].role == "leader"
let currentCommit := serverState[leader].commitIndex
let logLen := length(serverState[leader].log)
// Find highest index that has been replicated to a majority
for i from currentCommit + 1 to logLen:
let replicated := 1 // leader counts itself
forall s in servers \ {leader}:
if matchIndex[{ leader: leader, follower: s }] >= i:
replicated := replicated + 1
if replicated * 2 > size(servers) and
serverState[leader].log[i].term == serverState[leader].currentTerm {
serverState[leader].commitIndex := i
}
emit CommitAdvanced {
leader: leader,
commitIndex: serverState[leader].commitIndex
}
}
// Apply committed entries to state machine
action ApplyEntries(server: ServerId) {
require server in servers
let s := serverState[server]
let commitIdx := s.commitIndex
for i from s.lastApplied + 1 to commitIdx:
emit CommandApplied {
server: server,
index: i,
command: s.log[i].command
}
serverState[server].lastApplied := commitIdx
}
next:
StartElection
| GrantVote
| BecomeLeader
| AppendEntries
| AdvanceCommit
| ApplyEntries
}

View file

@ -99,7 +99,7 @@ export interface Task {
export type TaskType =
| "verify_speck" // Run Z3 verification on a Speck
| "compile_to_dst" // Compile verified Speck to DST
| "compile_to_wasm" // Compile DST to WASM
| "compile_to_wasm // Removed: WASM superseded by IR→Rust→wasm-pack path
| "generate_code" // Generate code from verified Speck
| "generate_docs" // Generate documentation from provenance graph
| "integrate" // Integration/glue code